Consultant Private vs NHS Session Calculator
Hospital consultants with a substantial NHS salary and growing private practice income can face effective marginal rates well above 60% on a single extra private session. This calculator shows exactly what you keep after income tax, Class 4 National Insurance, and the NHS Pension annual allowance taper interaction are deducted. Enter your NHS pensionable pay, the pension input amount from your annual allowance statement, your existing private income, and the value of the session you are considering to see the true net.
Ask a medical accountant about your figureConsultant Private vs NHS Session Calculator
Hospital consultants with a substantial NHS salary and growing private practice income can face effective marginal rates well above 60% on a single extra private session. This calculator shows exactly what you keep after income tax, Class 4 National Insurance, and the NHS Pension annual allowance taper interaction are deducted. Enter your NHS pensionable pay, the pension input amount from your annual allowance statement, your existing private income, and the value of the session you are considering to see the true net.
Your NHS salary or sessional pay that counts as pensionable. This counts toward threshold income.
The growth in the value of your pension this year, across every registered scheme, as shown on your annual allowance statement. This is the figure adjusted income adds back, and it is not the same as the contributions paid in.
Private practice income already earned or committed for the tax year, before the extra session you are considering.
The gross fee from the single additional private session. The calculator shows how much of this you actually keep.
Any other taxable income that counts toward the threshold income test. Leave at zero if none.
The extra session pushes adjusted income to £270,000, triggering the AA taper. Your annual allowance falls from £60,000 to £55,000 (a £5,000 reduction), adding an AA charge impact of £2,250. 2026/27 basis. Threshold income is the sum of NHS pay, private income, and other income (own pension contributions reduce threshold income but are not captured here, so the estimate may be conservative). Adjusted income adds back the pension input amount you entered, per FA 2004 s.228ZA. The AA charge impact is modelled as the AA reduction multiplied by the marginal income-tax rate; your actual charge depends on whether total pension input for the year would otherwise have stayed within the allowance. Carry-forward of unused allowance from the prior three tax years may eliminate the charge entirely. Class 4 NI is applied to private income only. These are estimates, not advice. At an effective marginal rate of 62.0%, the extra session keeps only £5,700 of every £15,000 earned. Check whether carry-forward of unused annual allowance from the previous three tax years can remove the AA charge before declining the session.
Estimate your tax as a salaried or self-employed doctor
A calculator gives the shape of the answer. NHS pensions, the annual allowance taper and private-practice incorporation are unforgiving in the detail. Tell us your situation and one of our medical accountants who works with doctors will confirm your exact figure and the sensible next step. Enquiring commits you to nothing.
Get the full GP and doctor tax and accounts model and guide
Why the marginal rate on a private session can exceed 60%
A hospital consultant with a significant NHS salary and growing private practice income faces three separate deductions on each extra private session: income tax at the marginal rate (40% or 45% once total income is above £50,270 or £125,140 respectively), Class 4 National Insurance on the self-employed private income (6% up to £50,270, 2% above, for 2026/27), and potentially an NHS Pension annual allowance charge if the extra income pushes adjusted income above the taper threshold.
The annual allowance taper is the subtlest and most damaging interaction. The NHS Pension standard annual allowance is £60,000. It tapers downward where BOTH of the following apply: threshold income (broadly all your taxable income) exceeds £200,000, AND adjusted income (threshold income plus your pension input amount for the year, the figure on your annual allowance statement) exceeds £260,000. For every £2 of adjusted income above £260,000, the allowance shrinks by £1, down to a minimum of £10,000. A consultant on £150,000 NHS pay and £70,000 existing private income, whose annual allowance statement shows a £35,000 pension input amount, has an adjusted income of £255,000 before any extra session. A single extra session worth £15,000 pushes adjusted income to £270,000, triggering the taper and reducing the annual allowance from £60,000 to £55,000. If total pension input for the year exceeds the tapered allowance, the reduction in allowance is charged to income tax at the marginal rate. At these income levels that rate is 45%, so the £5,000 AA reduction costs £2,250 in additional tax. The session that looked like £15,000 gross nets £5,700.
The personal allowance taper adds a further complication between £100,000 and £125,140 of total income. In that band the personal allowance reduces by £1 for every £2 of additional income, creating an effective income-tax rate close to 60% on income in that range. This calculator models that interaction correctly by computing the personal allowance and income-tax bands dynamically rather than using a fixed higher-rate band width. Above £125,140 the effective income-tax rate drops back to 45%, but the AA taper and Class 4 NI can still push the combined effective marginal rate materially higher. The example above illustrates a combined effective rate of 62%.
Worked example: consultant with NHS pensionable pay £150,000, existing private income £70,000 and a pension input amount of £35,000 on their annual allowance statement, considering a single extra session worth £15,000. Threshold income (with extra session): £150,000 plus £70,000 plus £15,000 equals £235,000. Adjusted income: £235,000 plus the £35,000 pension input amount equals £270,000, which exceeds £260,000, so the taper fires. Annual allowance falls from £60,000 to £60,000 minus (£270,000 minus £260,000) divided by 2 equals £55,000. Without the extra session, adjusted income is £255,000, below the £260,000 threshold, so no taper applies. AA reduction caused by the extra session: £5,000. Income tax on the extra £15,000 (all in the 45% additional-rate band at this income level): £6,750. Class 4 NI on the extra £15,000 (all above the £50,270 upper profits limit): £300. AA charge impact: £5,000 multiplied by 45% equals £2,250. Total cost: £9,300. Net retained: £5,700. Effective marginal rate: 62.0%. The £35,000 pension input amount is an assumption for the example; use your own statement figure.
Before declining a private session on marginal-rate grounds, verify two things with your accountant. First, whether carry-forward of unused annual allowance from the previous three tax years can eliminate or reduce the AA charge entirely. If you had a lower pension input in prior years, your effective annual allowance for this year may be much higher than £60,000, removing the taper sting. Second, whether your actual pension input amount for the year will actually breach the tapered allowance. The AA charge only crystallises when pension input (not contributions paid) exceeds the allowance. These two factors can change the net picture materially, and they require your personal carry-forward history to model properly.
Frequently asked questions
What is the NHS Pension annual allowance taper and why does it matter here?
- The standard annual allowance for pension contributions is £60,000. For high earners it is reduced (tapered) where two conditions are both met: your threshold income exceeds £200,000, and your adjusted income exceeds £260,000. Adjusted income is threshold income plus your pension input amount for the year, which for a defined-benefit scheme such as the NHS scheme is the capitalised growth in your pension, not the contributions paid in. For every £2 of adjusted income above £260,000, the allowance shrinks by £1 to a minimum of £10,000. If the taper tips your pension input above the reduced allowance, you owe an AA charge at your marginal income-tax rate. For a consultant on £235,000 adjusted income, a single extra private session can be the trigger that fires this charge.
Why is the effective marginal rate sometimes above 60% or even 80%?
- Three charges can hit simultaneously on a single private session: income tax (45% at this income level), Class 4 NI (2% on income above £50,270), and an AA charge if the session triggers or deepens the taper. The AA charge is itself charged at the marginal income-tax rate (45%), so each £2 of AA reduction costs £0.90 in charge. Depending on how far above the £260,000 adjusted income threshold you land, the three charges combined can push the effective marginal rate above 60% and in severe taper cases above 80%. The calculator shows the exact figure for your inputs.
What is the pension input amount and why is it included?
- The pension input amount is the growth in the value of your pension over the tax year, measured across every registered scheme you belong to. For a defined-benefit scheme such as the NHS Pension Scheme it is the capitalised increase in your accrued benefits, not the contributions that went in, and NHSBSA sends it to you on an annual allowance statement. Adjusted income is threshold income plus that pension input amount, so a year with a large pay rise or a big service increase can move you across the £260,000 line even when your cash income barely changed. Enter the figure from your statement rather than estimating it from your salary.
Can carry-forward of unused annual allowance eliminate the charge?
- Yes, and it is one of the most effective ways to manage the taper. If your pension input was below your annual allowance in any of the previous three tax years, you can carry forward the unused portion and add it to the current year's allowance. This can absorb the taper reduction entirely. Carry-forward is not captured in this calculator because it requires your personal pension input history for three prior years. A specialist medical accountant can model it. If you are regularly near the taper threshold, maintaining a carry-forward schedule is essential planning.
Does Class 4 NI on private income interact with the Class 1 NI I pay on my NHS salary?
- Your NHS salary is subject to Class 1 employee NI through PAYE (8% on income between £12,570 and £50,270, then 2% above). Private practice income is self-employed income and attracts Class 4 NI instead. The upper profits limit (£50,270) is shared across both income types, so if your NHS salary already exceeds £50,270, all your private income falls in the 2% upper band rather than the 6% main band. This calculator models Class 4 on private income only, which is conservative for consultants whose NHS salary has already exhausted the Class 1 main-rate band.
What is not covered by this calculator?
- This calculator does not cover: carry-forward of unused annual allowance from prior years (can materially reduce or eliminate the AA charge); Scheme Pays elections for settling an AA charge via the pension scheme rather than cash; the interaction with any personal pension contributions you make (these reduce threshold income and can push you below the taper thresholds); superannuation employee contributions as a deduction from take-home pay; or tax on investment or rental income held in a corporate structure. For a full picture of your position, use the NHS Pension Annual Allowance calculator alongside this tool and speak to a specialist medical accountant.
Free consultation
Need help interpreting your result?
These calculators give a simplified estimate on standard rates. Your actual position depends on your NHS pension record, carry-forward entitlement, IR35 status and income from all sources. Send your position and one of our medical accountants will read the full picture.
- Medical work onlyNHS pension, practice accounts and private practice
- Read by a medical accountantYour enquiry goes to our accountants who work with doctors
- One position, not threePractice, pension and personal return read together
No obligation and no hard sell. If our specialists think your position is already right, they will tell you so.